Mystery Shade (Polish Pickup and Advent)

New Arrival
Crelly Thermal
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
4 Reviews

Sale price$14.99
In stock, ready to be shipped


New nail polish shades added!

Love a mystery? Then this nail polish is perfect for you! Your Cadillacquer Mystery Shades will be one of the following from either Polish Pickup or 2023 Advent Calendar:

  • Let's Go, Let's Go! Are You Not Scared Enough?
  • The Killing Moon
  • Let It Glow
  • Oxygen
  • If You're A Bird, I'm A Bird (Day 1)
  • You Always Have A Choice (Day 21)
  • Let Me In (Day 23)

0.5 fl oz (15 ml)5 Free (No Formaldehyde, No DBP, No Toluene, No Formaldehyde Resin, No Camphor)

Cadillacquer nail polishes are cruelty-free

Made in Switzerland


Q. I already have one/some of the possible shades (from Polish Pickup or from a previous Mystery Shade order) and don't want a duplicate. Can you help?

A. Leave a note in the Order Instructions when you checkout stating which shades you have already and we'll do our best to accommodate. 


4 reviews
  • C
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    4 minutes ago
    5 Stars

    Amazing! I bought 3 mystery polishes and They were so sweet to include the two I was hoping for and left an order note about! 😍

    Stunning polishes! Plus the 3rd polish they picked for me totally fits the vibe of the two I wanted but is still so different and beautiful! I really felt like they picked it just for me! 😃Packaged with care, love the helpful business card, and the little hand written note. I’m so so happy I purchased from here. I will absolutely be coming back to this shop in the future!! <3 Thank you!!

  • DF
    Darlene F.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    8 months ago
    Gorgeous colour!

    I won't spoil which colour I received but it is so beautiful. The quality is great as well, I used 3 coats just to get it nice an opaque, and it went on smooth and evenly. It was relatively chip resistant for the first 3-4 days, but I was painting a bedroom, raking leaves and washing my hands frequently, so it probably would have had better staying power if I wasn't doing so much manual work. Really pleased with it!

  • WL
    Wasylyna L.
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    8 months ago
    Love them!

    I ordered 3 mystery overpours and was able to request polishes! I was lucky enough to receive all 3 requests and have worn 2 of them. These polishes are so amazing. They have a long wear time and are super pretty!

  • R
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 year ago
    5 Stars

    The store was able to accommodate my request to try a new thermal polish - I got corundum, and I was happy to find that it still transitions.

Reviews LoadedReviews Added

You may also like

Recently viewed